Dessert is serious business. The Cool Jacks crew just made the very difficult decision to settle a question that’s been pondered in the office, and perhaps group chats, for far too long: what is the best ice cream sandwich flavor? We brought together a few sugar-loving friends, gave each of them a spoon and a napkin, and went to work on a task that was fun and tasty.

 

Our menu features well-known cookie ice cream combo options, such as the chocolate chip ice cream sandwich, and we also have some limited-time combinations that you will be thrilled you tried.

 

In this blog, we will share our judging criteria, introduce the flavor lineup, and reveal our rankings so you can run your own taste test at home. It’s playful, it’s messy, and yes, it’s scientifically delicious. 

 

The Criteria: How We Judged Each Flavor

 

For this epic taste test, we adhered to our official “Cool Jacks” method. Each flavor was rated based on:

 

• Balance of cookie and ice cream: Does each bite hit the sweet spot, or does one overpower the other?

• Texture: Chewy, creamy, crunchy? We’re picky.

• Flavor harmony: Does it make your taste buds sing?

• Melt factor: Manageable mess or meltdown disaster?

 

Think of it like a food show, but with more laughter, more crumb-covered fingers, and zero judgment if you eat three sandwiches at once. Every bite counts toward finding the best ice cream sandwich flavors.

 

Ranked: Cool Jacks' Top Ice Cream Sandwich Flavors

This is how our taste buds analyzed it after hours of intense snacking:

 

#1. Jack Frost (Double Chocolate with Mint Chip)

 

A chocolate lover’s dream cooled by a swirl of refreshing mint. The double chocolate cookies bring that deep cocoa bite, while the mint chip ice cream keeps things light and balanced. It’s indulgent yet breezy, for the cool kids, literally.

 

#2. Super Jack (Candy Cookies with Superman Ice Cream)

 

Colorful, nostalgic, and just plain fun, this flavor is a throwback to carefree summers. Candy-studded cookies sandwich the bright, swirled Superman ice cream we all know and love. It’s a playful mix that turns every bite into a celebration.

 

#3. Jack Attack (Snickerdoodle Cookies with Salted Caramel Ice Cream)

 

Warm cinnamon spice meets creamy caramel in this fan favorite. The soft snickerdoodle cookies pair perfectly with salted caramel swirls for a bite that’s both cozy and bold. Sweet, buttery, and just the right amount of daring.

 

#4. Jumping Jack (Peanut Butter Cookies with Chocolate Ice Cream)

 

This duo knows how to bring the flavor. The rich peanut butter cookies hit first, followed by that silky chocolate ice cream that ties it all together. It’s a power couple of classic dessert flavors, perfectly balanced from start to finish.

 

#5. Classic Jack (Chocolate Chip Cookies with Vanilla Ice Cream)

 

The one that started it all, and still the champion. Fresh-baked chocolate chip cookies hug smooth vanilla ice cream for the perfect bite every time. Simple, timeless, and undeniably the Cool Jacks gold standard.

That is our scoreboard today. Tomorrow your taste test might crown a different hero, and we love that. Grab a few, invite your crew, and tell us which combo earns your vote for the best ice cream sandwich flavors.

 

Behind the Flavors: How Cool Jacks Perfects Every Bite

You might still wonder what makes our ice cream sandwiches taste so unbelievably good. It truly comes down to the little things.

 

We bake our cookies in small batches for that perfect and chewy bite. Each pair of cookie and ice cream is then handcrafted to deliver that perfect “fresh-baked vs. frozen” moment in every single bite.

 

We believe texture is just as crucial as flavor. The moment you bite down, the cookie gives you that perfect, satisfying snap and crispness. And as it squishes, the ice cream has nowhere to go but to slide inescapably out between the two layers, giving you that “wow” factor every single time.

 

And the flavors? They're playful too, sometimes unbelievably nostalgic, and other times delightfully unexpected. Trust us, every sandwich is a new micro-adventure for your taste buds. It’s no wonder fans keep coming back for seconds and thirds, or they simply sneak a bite right from the freezer!

 

Every ice cream sandwich, from traditional chocolate chip to creative small-batch limited releases, feels made for your moment, whether a quiet summer afternoon, a boisterous birthday party, or any Tuesday.

 

Want to Taste Test for Yourself?

 

Now it’s your turn to decide which Cool Jacks flavor deserves the crown in your opinion. Grab our variety pack, throw a taste test with friends, or just treat yourself on a random Tuesday, as every bite is a little adventure.

 

Ready to snack? Order a Classic Jack variety pack and host your own taste test.

 

Share your rankings with Cool Jacks on Instagram and join the flavor debate online. One thing’s for sure, Cool Jacks makes every celebration, snack break, or midweek moment sweeter, one ice cream sandwich at a time.